My Horchata Romance

Meet Cute

We were introduced by a mutual friend, a buddy of mine who knew her from his days on the Mexican border.  We sat down in a dirty Mexican hole in the wall in (of all places) Provo, Utah, and there she was.  My buddy would go on to wait tables at the biggest Mexican place in town, but I still remember tiny Moya’s, its little bar and its warm, small tortillas.  That’s where I first saw Horchata.


It started as a fleeting crush, that’s all.  There was a mystery to it– milky look, but watery texture, cinnamon with a touch of citrus.  It takes time to understand a combination like that.  I moved on, Horchata did too.

I was still fiercely loyal to root beer back then.  I used to brew my own in Portugal, nursing my home-made bottles along just like all those winos out on the streets.  Root beer got me through those years, and I wasn’t about to walk away now that life was easier.

We moved to Washington D.C. and established a favorite Mexican place.  We probably went there 20 times in three years, and not once did I look for Horchata.  Time was precious and life was full—I wasn’t looking for anything serious.

Back in Utah, I wandered through a little street fair, just down the block from my apartment.  Chocolate bananas, fresh donuts, and then a taco stand, heavy on the fresh cilantro.  In the back, behind the tired old Mexican lady sitting on an overturned jug, there it was—a five gallon bucket, greasy on the outside, cooled on the inside with ice floating in a white pool of cinnamon motion.  It was the first I’d thought of it in years, but I was instantly thirsty.

street fair

In the heat of that day with a little plastic cup in my hand, it was made perfectly clear to me.  The watery thin-ness isn’t a lack of substance- it’s the exact scientific density of refreshment.  It is silk made out of sugar and rice, and it is the best thing at the fair, whatever fair you’re at.  It wasn’t a crush anymore.

Dramatic Tension

I started looking harder for it, but Horchata was evasive.  Mexican restaurants are everywhere, but some of them don’t have it, and some of them don’t have the real thing.  I realized that Horchata may be the most misunderstood of specialty ethnic drinks.  I tried to tell people- you can’t get Horchata from a syrup.  No, shouldn’t be thicker than milk.  Costa Vida mixes it as thick as rice pudding.  It’s delicious, but decadent.  Horchata without the innocence is hardly Horchata at all.

So I learned to make it myself.  The recipes are complicated.  I chose one that required pureeing raw rice in water and then straining it through a cheese cloth.  After an hour of sweaty labor, I looked down past my cheese cloth to see less than a cup of concentrated rice juice, like precious oil pressed from olives.  It made me doubt my devotion.  I mixed it up into Horchata anyway.  It was good, not great.  Two kids strolled by and took a swig.  “Hmm,” said one.  “Needs more . . . taste.”  “Yeah,” said the other.  “More taste.”  Whatever.

Earlier this year we went on a vacation to Mexico.  I asked for Horchata.  “What?” said all the waiters in the touristy resort towns.  No one had heard of it.  Macy asked me if I had made the whole Horchata thing up.  Maybe it’s actually from Brazil? she asked, or maybe it’s just an American novelty trying to pass as an exotic import?  She likes watching me bristle.

Boy Gets Drink

We come home from Mexico, and I think about moving on.  Those virgin margaritas down there were nice—maybe there’s a fling to be had.  Or maybe just accept adulthood and sign up for a tedious life of Diet Coke.  It’s depressing, but I start to resign myself.

Down at the food court, a new restaurant opens- a satellite outpost of Red Iguana.  I don’t even think about the implications.

red iguana

The day of the grand opening, I order the chile verde.  “Do you want a drink?”  I eye the soda fountain.  It’s boring.  “You like Horchata?”  Bells ring.  Mexican angels sing—arias backed by castanets and Spanish guitars.  The cash register closes.  I swallow it all before I start to understand what it means.  It’s close to authentic.  Thin, smooth, the taste comes to you only after a few gulps.  Perfect.  Then I see.  It’s not just one cup now.  It’s in my life– for good– just a few feet from my office.  I won’t ever want for Horchata again.  And it doesn’t require a cheese cloth either.  Thank you, Mexico.

This entry was posted in Obsessions, Travel. Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to My Horchata Romance

  1. Eliza says:

    lol. seriously really clever and funny. loved your kids critique, “needs more taste” lol. I have never tried horchata but your description of it being watery actually grosses me out, maybe I should try the costa vida version, the richer the better.

  2. Braden says:

    “Bells ring. Mexican angels sing—arias backed by castanets and Spanish guitars.” Excellent. Great post, Ry.

  3. Christian says:

    That’s exactly how I feel about blood sausage. Mmmmm. Oh wait, no it’s not. Because just like blood sausage Horchata sounds gross.

    Ok, I admit your description of it did make me a little curious, even though it’s always sounded gross, because I’ve always had this idea that refreshing drinks shouldn’t have anything to do with millk or milkiness, but then I remembered discovering those Sobe drinks on my mission, on the hot humid days of the American South. The yellow and pink kinds were so good, and they seemed to have a milk influence.

    I’ll give horchata a try.

  4. craftyashley says:

    So I should not buy the large plastic barrel labeled “Horchata” in the grocery store next to the Orange Juice?

  5. Landon says:

    Christian, stick with the pink sobe. I have tried to acquire the taste for horchata but haven’t yet. I usually like the first few sips and then I’m done. Funny that Macy thought you made it up. I’ve heard La Puente has some pretty good horchata, pick up the small combination plate while your there.

  6. Troy says:

    Easy recipe for Horchata (no cheese cloths necessary):

    -Pour a bowl of Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal
    -Eat the cereal
    -Pour the leftover milk in the bowl into a cup
    -Enjoy your Horchata

  7. Ryan says:

    Kook. Horchata doesn’t have milk in it. Totally different thing. Just try it a few times. It’s so good.

    Ashley, you have read the message of my post correctly. That would be the wrong thing to do.

    Landon, hadn’t heard of La Puente. We’re definitely going to make a stop there. Maybe tonight for my birthday, come to think of it.

    Norm, that song made me buy that album. Crappy decision, by the way. But great topic for a song.

    Troy, I admit your comment made me laugh. It was wrong-headed, ignorant, and infantile. But funny.

  8. Gina says:

    I grew up in Phoenix, and real Mexican places abound, and a LOT of them make Horchata. I somehow didn’t try it until I was 19, and the texture was so similar to the texture of the stuff I had to drink when I had an MRI done that I almost threw it up.

    My husband still harbors resentment that I don’t love Horchata like he does. It warms his heart better than Christmas.

  9. Mexican angels sing…lol. Can’t say I’m ever gonna try it though.

  10. I too am a horchata lover. My first experience was as a teenager at Tio’s – a little Mexican restaurant near my house in Murray, UT. That first drink was magical, but subsequent purchases never quite measured up. Maybe Tio was on his game that first time. When on a trip in Mexico, the wife of my business contact made dinner for us one night and the food was nothing to celebrate, but she did make horchata and it took me back to that first drink at Tio’s….so delicioso. I haven’t had a good horchata for a while now, but Cafe Rio makes a good batch if you get it fresh early in the day. I’m only dissappointed you didn’t make a mariachi music reference, because would’ve hecho my whole dia!

  11. Jeff says:

    Dude… Go to the church and clean the chalkboards, collect the dust and add it to water. Horchalkta. Different name, different recipe, same taste. Next you are going to say you don’t like German food or something absurd like that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s